Should Where You Live Determine Where Your Kid Goes to School?

Is it fair that a student is barred from attending a superior public school because of where he or she lives? This debate isn't new. While its current incarnation is geography, the heart of the issue revolves around the intersection between class and race.

Find available tutors


The Current Controversy

In April, Tanya McDowell was arrested and charged with first degree grand larceny for the amount of $15,686. Why? Because she enrolled her 6-year-old son in Norwalk, Connecticut's Brookside Elementary School from September of 2010 through January of 2011. According to Norwalk Public Schools, McDowell wasn't a legal resident and therefore she was stealing educational services. McDowell claimed she was homeless when she registered her son and spending part of her time at a friend's home in Norwalk, which would have made her eligible for the school.

This case follows that of Kelley Williams-Bolar of Akron, Ohio. Williams-Bolar served nine days in jail earlier this year for lying on school registration forms in order to get her two daughters into a better Akron school district than where they lived. Both mothers received national attention and stirred a growing debate about the fairness of access to the public school system.

A Long Legacy of Discrimination

The 1954 landmark Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka was, in theory, a watershed moment in education. It overturned the 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson case that made segregation legal. The Brown case established that the school system was separate but unequal. It was determined that, in practice, African American students had access to disproportionately inferior schools than their white peers. The Supreme Court decided that this was a form of discrimination barred by the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Yet the case has failed to resolve the issue of de facto segregation. Today, parents like McDowell and Williams-Bolar fret over sending their children to their local school when another public school with far better resources and educational opportunities may be only a few miles away. In order to get their children enrolled in nearby schools, they must break the law. Yet they do so in order to provide their children with the best local public education they can find.

Separate But Unequal

The Brown v. Board of Education case was about overt racial discrimination. Yet while schools cannot prevent students from attending based on race, they can based on geography. This system is superficially fair. Since public schools typically receive substantial funding from local taxpayers, it's logical that those who pay taxes in the area should benefit from how those dollars are spent and those in areas with fewer tax dollars coming in would have inferior schools.

However, this begs the question of whether class should dictate access to education. If district lines are drawn based on property values, more tax money flows into the schools of wealthy neighborhoods while the schools in poorer neighborhoods flounder. The issue is further complicated by the relationship between race and class. Both McDowell and Williams-Bolar are African American. While the Supreme Court seemingly resolved the issue of equal access to education more than half a century ago, it's clear that discrimination still exists.

Did you find this useful? If so, please let others know!

Other Articles You May Be Interested In

  • More Blog Articles
    Should IT Matter How Your Child's Teacher Dresses?

    Dress codes have long been a staple in many schools across the country. In some cases, students and even parents have opposed them. But what about dress codes for teachers? When it comes to this issue, just where do most people stand? And should a teacher's clothing even be of concern to parents?

  • More Blog Articles
    How Can You Know if College Is Right for Your Child?

    A prevailing school of thought is that most people need college in order to be successful. But this certainly may not always be the case. Quite simply, not everyone is college material. If your teen will soon be graduating from high school, you may need to contemplate whether college is right for your child.

We Found 7 Tutors You Might Be Interested In

Huntington Learning

  • What Huntington Learning offers:
  • Online and in-center tutoring
  • One on one tutoring
  • Every Huntington tutor is certified and trained extensively on the most effective teaching methods
In-Center and Online


  • What K12 offers:
  • Online tutoring
  • Has a strong and effective partnership with public and private schools
  • AdvancED-accredited corporation meeting the highest standards of educational management
Online Only

Kaplan Kids

  • What Kaplan Kids offers:
  • Online tutoring
  • Customized learning plans
  • Real-Time Progress Reports track your child's progress
Online Only


  • What Kumon offers:
  • In-center tutoring
  • Individualized programs for your child
  • Helps your child develop the skills and study habits needed to improve their academic performance
In-Center and Online

Sylvan Learning

  • What Sylvan Learning offers:
  • Online and in-center tutoring
  • Sylvan tutors are certified teachers who provide personalized instruction
  • Regular assessment and progress reports
In-Home, In-Center and Online

Tutor Doctor

  • What Tutor Doctor offers:
  • In-Home tutoring
  • One on one attention by the tutor
  • Develops personlized programs by working with your child's existing homework
In-Home Only


  • What TutorVista offers:
  • Online tutoring
  • Student works one-on-one with a professional tutor
  • Using the virtual whiteboard workspace to share problems, solutions and explanations
Online Only

Our Commitment to You

  • Free Help from Teachers

  • Free Learning Materials

  • Helping Disadvantaged Youth